Allyson Johnson

Pieces of my Mind

Book Club Questions: The Three Lives of Mary Sutton

Book Club Questions

The Three Lives of Mary Sutton prompts readers to consider larger social questions about sexuality, motherhood, and social expectations for women in the 1880’s and the present.

  1. Do you think Mame Sutton is a reliable narrator? 
  2. Mame Sutton makes quick judgements about people. How good a judge of character is she? 
    1. Her judgment of the Widow? 
    1. Of Joseph Nicholson? 
    1. Of Mickey Carmichael? 
    1. Of Eleanor Rush?
  3. Both Mame and Lizzie leap into marriage as a way of getting away.  What other options might they have had at that time? 
  4. Neither Lizzie nor Mame ends up with the life they expected after marriage.  Which of the two sisters comes closest to your idea of living Happily Ever After?
  5. Joseph Cohen’s family is large, cohesive, and upper-middle class.  Why would it be hard for Lizzie to fit into this family?  How might she have welcomed the Utah move?  What risks did she run?
  6. Compare Mame’s and Lizzie’s ideas about the kind of home they want. 
  • How might Mame’s relationship with Joseph have been changed if their sex life had been more satisfying to Mame? 
  • Mame listens to Joe and Lizzie talking together in bed and wonders what she is missing.  How has she failed to communicate with her husband, and he with her?
  • Mame has a hard time getting to feel motherly toward her child.  Why do you think this is?
  • How were social expectations for women different in the 1880’s? How are they the same?
  • How does Mame fail to meet social expectations?  Is this because of her nature, because of the way she was raised, because of her experiences?  Or some combination?
  • Can you think of a time when you struggled to meet social expectations?  When you succeeded?  When you failed?
  • One reader complained that the ending felt rushed and she wanted to know more of what happened.  Were you satisfied by the ending of the novel? 
  • One reader felt that the story was written as a feminist rant against men.  Did you feel that the men in the story were believable?  Fairly portrayed?
  • Nellie Young discarded her husband’s name and refused to let him be talked about, even to her son.  What would you have done in her situation? 
  • Are there family stories and family members in your history that are not discussed?  How did you understand as a child that questions in this area were not welcomed? 
  • If someone in your family history was a criminal or a blackguard, would you want to know? How far back in your history would you care? At what point would it become just a story?
  • Mame’s decisions at crucial moments change her life’s direction.  Can you think of a decision you made that put you on a different path?